Saturday, March 24, 2007

A Model for Autonomy in Language Learning

Chia, Christian Shyh Chiuan. Promoting independent learning through language learning and the use of IT.

In this article the author describes an interesting program in Singapore that stresses learner autonomy to learn English. The students, many from the People’s Republic of China, traditionally are not accustomed to much autonomy in regard to their education. The students are required to work in the self-access centre (SAC) for 1 hour each week. While there they use the school’s web environment to access different materials.

When I read something like this, I think, “This is how education is supposed to be.” Implementing a program like this often seems impossible for several reasons. It goes against the basic infrastructure and so many of the norms of our school systems. We are used to thinking that the student can’t make these decisions for themselves.

I was glad to see that the SAC program described in this article address many of the potential problems that people would so quickly point out. Students are trained about the many different ways they may use their time. Students are held accountable for their time by having to create a plan (which they can change at any time). They are also held accountable by posting weekly reports telling how they spent their time.

I don’t think I would be received well if I told the administration at my school that for one day every week, I would set up a wide variety of language activities for my students that are not necessarily related to the other content we are looking at in class or even designed specifically for students at their level, and that I would let the students spend the time however they choose. I, however, can see great value in feeding that curiosity and sense of exploration and independence in my students. Often I hear my students saying that we aren’t getting to what they wanted to learn yet. Why not give them the opportunity to go right for what they personally want to know. When those questions are answered, they’ll have more questions. As long as they are learning, does it matter if I am guiding their journey every moment?

Transform you City: a webquest

Firsty I want to thank John for the link in this week's discussion that led me to this webquest. Gracias. :)

Website Evaluation: Transform Your City

URL: http://home.comcast.net/~battla44/Bogota2015/webquest.htm

For: upper elementary or middle school students
Subjects: social studies, language arts, foreign language, technology, or enrichment classes

The purpose of this webquest is to guide students to discover their city’s past, explore its present strengths and needs, and to create a plan to make improvements for the city’s future.

The webquest is well-organized. It has clear steps and requirements. The task is interesting and engaging.

The webquest offers many resources that the students might need while completing the tasks. It has links to several external documents. These include:
1) a fact-finder sheet to help them organize research and keep track of sources
2) a needs assessment sheet
3) an outline for the presentation
4) rubrics for the research, the booklet (written product), and the presentation

If one were able to create additional external documents and edit the existing rubrics it could be used for a Foreign Language class to practice writing, vocabulary about cities, or the future tense.

The webquest does not offer specific practice or feedback for any language goals.

The strengths of this webquest are that it is well-organized, it offers clear description of tasks, and clear steps to follow.

One area to improve is in the task description for creating a booklet. In each step it says, “click here for an example,” but there are no examples.

Sunday, March 11, 2007

Wetpaint

So... I'm not sure how I forgot to mention the coolest result of our Wikis in education search this week. After clicking through several levels of links and resources on one of the pages I found, I stumbled upon www.wetpaint.com

My big goal for a 'website' is to create a community of learners that includes former students, current students, and anyone else who has finished or is taking a break in their formal language education. Since the goals are building community, communication, and learning from each other, it makes sense to build a wiki.

Wetpaint was so easy to use. I was actually playing around, and not plannign on building it yet, when all of a sudden, it was done! I'll invite you all to take a look... and join... very soon. Until then, go check out wetpaint yourself.

There are two other things that impressed me about wetpaint. First, it looks great. Some of the sites I read during this week's activities critiqued wikis as being generally ugly. These wikis are organized and asthetically pleasing. Second, the tutorials and other elements of the page make it really easy to use the full potential of what wetpaint has to offer. They also really make it seem like a space for all (all those I invite, or open to all if I choose).

Okay, so check out wetpaint, and tell me what you think.

Saturday, March 10, 2007

Wikis in Online Education

Evaluation of http://wik.ed.uiuc.edu/index.php/Wikis_in_Online_Education

After completing the Evaluation Checklist, I had a few questions about the purpose for this wiki. It is hosted by the University of Illinois At Urbana-Champagne. There seems to be one main contributor and a few other secondary contributors. I was unable to tell if this is a source of information about wikis for the faculty or if this is the product of a student’s research.

The information seemed very accurate and thorough. It is presented in a very organized, professional manner.

Under the heading What Types of WIKIs? is a list of types of wikis. I found especially interesting http://wikibooks.org .

Find just what you are looking for here... and here... and here!

This assignment helped me realize that being a creature of habit has limited what I find out on the web. I always search Yahoo! or Google. I did not realize that they could be much more efficient tools than I had previously seen. I also did not realize that for some situations other search engines might be more appropriate.

The 3 search engines I chose to try out this week are:

www.lycos.com
www.marcopolosearch.org
www.altavista.com

Lycos is powered by Ask.com. The neatest feature of Lycos that I noticed was that after clicking on a link, it opened up a frame on the left side of the screen that kept your search results open. This way after viewing a link, you do not have to go to your Back button to find your results again.

Alta Vista seemed to come up with the most interesting links. Many of them were actual wikis people had created to talk about the uses of wikis in education.

Although it returned only one hit, I was most interested in Marco Polo Search. Despite the URL, the search engine seems to actually be called Thinkfinity, and it is somehow associated with Verizon wireless. Thinkfinity is a search engine designed specifically for k-12 educators. It searches about 7 different sites that carry educational resources from articles to lesson plans. Some of the materials it returns are “partner reviewed”. The search is much more limited than Google, but it would a good place to go if you are looking specifically for online content for your classroom. For more specific searches I ran it gave me just a few hits. I decided to try a more general search and searched the word Spain. It returned 234 hits. They were not organized in any useful way from what I could see. The results I got from doing a narrower search were much more useful.

Saturday, March 3, 2007

Still searching for ideas about individualized instruction in the CALL classroom

My immediate reaction to this article is that Dan was correct when he said the article doesn’t do a good job with talking about learning styles, multiple intelligences, or individualized instruction. My second reaction is that the author is somewhat out of touch with a real classroom environment.

The article did offer an introduction to the idea of learning styles and multiple intelligences. Hopefully, none of this information was new or surprising to anyone active in the field of education.

I did not really care for the suggestions for activities to introduce the concepts of learning styles and multiple intelligences to the students. Assuming that we all have access to each of the programs that offer different ways to organize information, the activity did not allow students to play around with each one before deciding which they would like best. I prefer to have the students complete an activity that would suggest to them which learning style or intelligence they lean to, and then suggest a software program they might prefer.

At one point the author says, “Many language teachers in CALL classrooms find it necessary to have students work in groups in order to increase the time spent at the computer during a task.” I thought that statement summed up my disappointment with this article. The focus seems to be on getting the students using the computer. It overlooked that the goal should be language focused.

My critique of computer based mind mapping programs is that they can stifle creativity rather than enhance it. No matter how many ways or how easily the program allows the user to draw the mind map, it is still more limited than what a person can do on paper with a pencil. The user is also focusing on which tool to use and where to find it.

Computer based mind mapping tools often have really cool features that allow the user to switch their product from a mind map or web to an outline or another format. They also are really useful when the mind map is something that needs to be published. However, for most practical uses, a mind map can be dirty, sloppy, and does not need to be published.

I believe the author was trying to make obtainable suggestions to the reader by making them more general. The suggestion for a thematic project seemed to be based on an actual project the author had implemented or observed, but was then generalized. By making it more general it seemed to suggest that a teacher would search for heart transplant patients of a specific age and in a specific country for the project. The idea seemed really impersonal and a little scary to me. Now if the teacher happened to know of this sick child before, or had a previous connection to a hospital in a foreign country, this project might make a little more sense.

I have to say that after reading this article I do not really have any new ideas about how I can use computers in my classroom to meet the individual needs of my students as we learn a new language.

I feel as though I’ve critiqued this article pretty harshly. Does anyone agree with me? Did anyone else get some great ideas after reading this article that I somehow in a strange period of pessimism overlooked?